
Posted:
Sun Feb 19, 2006 3:26 am
by bongoron
Is it same to assume one of the forum members is playing this solo? Whoever it is, I like it!
I don't remembere where I got this...please confess if this is you.
very cool solo
If this didn't upload, Please let me know.
Edited By bongoron on 1140319906

Posted:
Sun Feb 19, 2006 5:59 pm
by Berimbau
Bongoron,
I try not to be critical of other plavers, but Johnny is right. This don't heat my grease too much. Percussionist need to hear the bigger musical picture and try to play melodically. Rhythm and speed alone won't cut it with us experienced oldtimers. Better you should wait for Johnny's video. Trust me, you'll learn a few things from him!
Saludos,
Berimbau

Posted:
Sun Feb 19, 2006 10:32 pm
by SkinDeep
I AGREE A SOLO IS A WORK OF ART, NOT A CHANCE TO TRY TO SHOW OFF!!!

Posted:
Mon Feb 20, 2006 2:58 pm
by ABAKUA
??? ??? ???
Are we seeing the same clip here Bongoron? Sorry to be critical, but extemely poor technique, no heart or sabor, typical tippy tap hippy drum circle like player.
Didnt dig it at all.
If you dig that clip, then you need to get out and see more players doing there thing... :;):

Posted:
Mon Feb 20, 2006 9:54 pm
by bongoron
Unfortunately there is no "out" to get to around here. Maybe you guys could post one of your videos up so I could see/hear what you're talking about. Frankly, I hear many different tones when I listen to this with my eyes closed. Also many different intensity levels. Since he is unaccompanied, why does he need a melody? The other two guys are just waiting to come in. What is wrong with speed? I'm just curious...looked like some skill to me. Please be specific on his technical flaws, and on what I've missed by enjoying this short clip...a video clip from one of you guys perhaps?
Actually, never mind. I just listened to a hildalgo clip (without video) from the LP site. His is just as random and only has a couple of melodic spots that don't repeat throughout the solo. He isn't using only two drums either. I guess I just have a different musical taste...I like them both, and appreciate the efforts of both (I'm not putting that guy equal to hidalgo). I do like a variety of clearly audible tone differences, though. Just loud and fast and mostly slaps on the quinto, with occaisional sloppy open tones isn't good enough for me either. I do hear the variety I like in the clip I posted...heel-tip, closed slaps, open tones, slaps, muted tones, whatever..would like more bass tones, but that's just me. That's what I hear...eyes closed.
If you want to post your own, go ahead. Maybe I can see/hear what you're talking about. Otherwise, I won't get it. I watched (and saved) Abakua's video with the short solo toward the end...Seemed short, fast, and very bland to me. No offense, but with my eyes closed..that's what I hear. I'm interested in the finer technical aspects, but not if they require me to hate what looks and sounds like playing from the heart.
I just made a video with just Abakua's solo and the other one back to back. This allows a close comparison of one following the other. My daughter picked the other one, and so did her friend. Although one of them is a "tippy tap, hippy drum circle " player, the other isn't, and both were disinterested observers. Since they basically acted in a "audience" role...I guess the performance really depends on the audience. Clearly, a paying audience will attend the style it prefers.
My original question was regarding the identity of this player. Thanks for the other comments, but without some video examples, I guess I remain ignorant of what "Real" conga playing is, and I still like it. I guess you guys must really hate Pete Lockett!
Edited By bongoron on 1140476285