by davidpenalosa » Mon Sep 26, 2005 6:25 pm
Hi Rey,
I’d like to offer my 2 cents to the clave discussion.
There are no 3-2 or 2-3 rhythms per se. 3-2, 2-3 refers to where a part begins. If a song or instrumental part begins within the three-side (or on a pick-up into the three-side) it’s in a 3-2 clave sequence (or 3-2 clave "direction"). If a song begins within the two-side side (or on a pick-up into the two-side), it’s in 2-3 clave.
In folkloric music "one" is considered to be the first beat of the three-side, whether or not the song is in 3-2 or 2-3. The clave or 6/8 bell begins on the three-side. A 2-3 folkloric song is considered to be in the second half, or "back" of the rhythm. As a folkloric percussionist, you need to know if the particular part you are playing requires you to enter in a specific place within clave. If it does, you will enter in that place regardless if the accompanying song is in 3-2 or 2-3.
In popular music a chord progression may begin on either side of clave. "One" is the beginning of the chord progression, so depending on the song, "one" may occur on either side of the clave. As a popular music percussionist you need to be able to begin your part on either side of clave, depending upon where the chord progression begins.
3-2, 2-3 is a popular music concept and terminology. It can be helpful in understanding folkloric rhythms, but it can also get in the way of that understanding.
-David