congamyk wrote:Quinto Governor II wrote:Congamyk,
I think secular music, most notable jazz was more of an influence on gospel, than gospel influencing jazz.
The exact opposite is the case. Almost all jazz musicians in the early stages of jazz grew up in the church and harken back to gospel music as thier original influence and roots. Nearly all pianists grew up playing and learning in church in those days. Money was scarce and pianos were few and far between. Nearly every major jazz great and influence attributes gospel music as thier start. I could list hundreds that have publicly expressed this. If you read anything at all about jazz you would know this.Also, I believe it has already been established than there was more going on than just one musician playing a Cuban tune.
Even Jelly Roll Morton grew up playing in church. If there was another musician or even more so what? There are hundreds of musicians that were forming the music known as jazz, not just Jelly Roll. He is one small piece and all he did was reference a "Spanish tinge" that came up from Mexico and was from Spain. How does that single reference make "Cuba" influencial? You can't build a thesis on an obscure reference like that.Just as those Latin and American musicians were listening to and playing with each other in New York, the same had already taken place earlier in New Orleans, and that is simply influence enough for me.
Jazz didn't make it's way to New York for decades. How could the musicians you talk about in New York play jazz when they didn't know about it? Jazz didn't make it's way north for a few decades. Remember we are talking about the turn of the century. The few latin people in the US here had little to NO influence at all and anything new traveled slowly. Were any of these Latin musicians in New Orleans in 1905? No, there was no Latin influence in the early development of jazz. Just be satisfied that Latin jazz did take off with greats Like Chano and others decades later. Don't try to rewrite history.
Users browsing this forum: No registered users and 64 guests