by BMac » Tue Feb 19, 2008 6:09 pm
I thinks the Tocas have wider hardware than LP Classics. In the Tocas, the metal bands have bigger diameters (relative to the shells) and stand further out from the shells. You can carry a Toca by inserting your fingers deep into the space between the skin and the shell. With an LP classic, you can't get as much of your hand in the space, it's a tighter fit. I'm mentioning this carry method to clarify the distinction between the two types of hardware/shell arrangement ... wider versus tighter fitting hardware. I don't care how a conga is carried so long as she ain't dropped.
I believe, however, the sound is affected greatly. So the Tocas don't sound like the LP Classics. I'm not choosing one over the other as better. But there is a difference in the sound. The angle of the skin from the hardware to the bearing edge of the shell is affected. So the relationship of tension in the bolts to the surface tension in the skin is affected. The sound is affected.
I think the tighter fitting hardware on the LP Classics or any similar drum promotes pure and simple tones. I think such hardware is especially beneficial in the congas (segundo) and tumbas where I want to hear lower true tones. You can mount new skins really shallow on drums like these.
I think the wider hardware on the Tocas or any similar drum produces a more complex, mixed frequency, sound. I hear more highs. The wider hardware may be a better choice, according to your tastes, for quintos and requintos. Look at the LP Giovanni Palladium series, their hardware is wider than the LP Classics, relative to the shells. In that sense, this LP series is more like the Tocas than are the LP Classics.
I think it's a players choice. Of course there are likely many other differences in the various drums.
I played for a couple of hours in a park on Sunday with a friend. He played conga/quinto with wider hardware and did more improv and solos. I played tumba/conga with tighter fitting hardware and held the basic rhythms together while he jammed. Our sounds didn't conflict at all. Everything was clear and well heard. Single moms stopped and danced a bit while their kids sang eency-beency-spider with me while I played mambo rhythms. Hey there momma!
That's what I thinks!
Cheers
BMac
Edited By BMac on 1203444660